Pie In the Sky Pizza Menu (Update 2025)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to Pie In the Sky Pizza, the quintessential destination for New York-style pizza in the heart of Charlotte. Nestled at 124 Brevard Court, this cozy eatery captures the essence of a classic New York deli, serving up deliciously authentic slices that have long been sought after by transplanted New Yorkers.

The menu boasts a wide array of hearty options, featuring not only their signature pizzas but also standout items like the mouthwatering Philly cheesesteak. Customers rave about the quality and freshness of every dish, from piping hot pizzas to flavorful Reubens. Exceptional service complements the experience, ensuring each guest feels right at home.

Whether you’re stopping by for a quick bite at lunch or catering a team event, Pie In the Sky Pizza guarantees satisfaction and excellence in every order. Don’t miss out on this slice of heaven! Their motto? “Forgetaboutit!”
Starters
Salads
Pasta
Subs
Pizza

Starters

Garlic Bread
US$4.94

Cheese Bread
US$6.19

Garlic Knotts

3 pieces.
US$3.74

Stromboli

Stuffed with matz.
US$12.50

Calzone

Ricotta, matz cheese.
US$12.50

Wings

BBQ, Buffalo, lemon pepper, garlic Parmesan.
US$20.00

Fries
US$4.94

Onion Rings
US$4.94

Fried Matz Cheese Sticks
US$11.19

Potato Salad
US$4.94

Pasta Salad
US$4.94

Chicken Tenders
US$11.19

Strawberry Salad

Strawberry, grapes, fetta cheese, mixed nuts, avocado, tomato.
US$18.69

Caesar Salad

Tomato, Parmesan cheese, provolone cheese.
US$18.69

Greek Salad

Fetta cheese, Kalamata olives, onions, tomato, cucumber.
US$18.69

House Salad

Tomato, cucumber, matz cheese, onios, balsamic dressing.
US$18.69

Chef Salad

Ham, eggs, onions, tomato, matz cheese, cucumber.
US$18.69

Salads

Pasta

Beef Lasagna
US$12.44

Spaghetti Meat Balls

Served with 3 large meat balls.
US$12.44

Meat Balls Sub

3 meat balls topped with matz cheese, provolone, marinara sauce.
US$13.13

Chicken Parm Sub

Chicken topped with matz cheese.
US$14.94

Hot Italian Sub

Pepperoni, ham, salami, provolone cheese, matz cheese, peppers onion.
US$13.13

Vegetarian Sub

Tomato, onions, bannana peppers, roasted peppers, olives, mushrooms.
US$13.13

Italian Sausage Sub

8" Italian sausage, green peppers, sauteed onios, marinara sauce, matz cheese.
US$13.13

Chicken Caesar Sub

Provolone, lettuce, chicken, Caesar dressing, matz cheese.
US$13.13

Pizza Sub

Provolone, pepperoni, Italian sausage, marinara sauce, matz cheese.
US$13.13

Philly Steak Sub

Shredded steak, peppers, onions, white American cheese.
US$13.13

Italian Chicken Sub

Grilled chicken, peppers, onions, provolone cheese.
US$13.13

Burger

1/2 lb. burger, lettuce, tomato, ketchup, mustard, mayonnaise.
US$14.94

South Western Burger

1/2 lb. burger, chilli, slaw, Swiss cheese, onion, mustard.
US$16.19

Bacon Cheese Burger

1/2 lb. burger, lettuce, tomato, ketchup, mustard, mayonnaise.
US$16.19

Reuben Sub

Rye bread, Russian dressing, Reuben, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese.
US$14.94

Cuban Sub

Pulled pork BBQ, mustard, ham, pickles, Swiss cheese.
US$14.94

Roast Beef Sub

Roast beef, lettuce, tomato, onion, mustard, mayo.
US$14.94

TBLT Sub

Turkey, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, bacon, mayonnaise.
US$13.69

Chicken Salad Sandwich

Diced chicken breast, mustard, tomato, onions, lettuce, over Texas toast.
US$13.69

Spicy Chicken Sub

Breaded chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, pickles, Buffalo sauce.
US$14.94

Subs

Pizza

Cheese Pizza

Gluten-Free Pizza

Personal size 10" cauliflower gluten-free pizza.
US$17.50

Pepperoni Pizza

Gyro Lamb Pizza

Gyro meat, tzatziki sauce base, onion, tomato, topped with tzatziki glaze.

Philly Steak Pizza

Philly steak meat, matz cheese, onion, peppers, topped with cheddar cheese.

Ziti Meat Balls Pizza

Sliced meatballs, baked zitti, ricotta cheese, onions, cilantro.

Meat Lovers Pizza

Pepperoni, ham, bacon, sausage.

Pulled Pork BBQ Pizza

Pulled pork BBQ, onions, cilantro.

Chorizo, Taste Of Spain Pizza

Chorizo sausage, jalapeno, tomato, onions, cilantro.

BBQ Chicken Pizza

Diced grilled BBQ chicken, onions, cilantro.

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Diced grilled Buffalo chicken, homemade Buffalo sauce.

Chicken Florentine Pizza

Red or white sauce, diced marinated chicken, fresh spinach, matz cheese.

Hawaiian Pizza

Pineapple, ham, bacon.

Margarita Pizza

Fresh basil, fresh sliced matz cheese, fresh sliced tomato, pesto sauce. Vegetarian.

Vegetarian Pizza

Olives, onions, mushrooms, banana peppers, roasted peppers, green peppers. Vegetarian.

Medeteranian White Pizza

White garlic sauce, fresh spinach, tomato, onions, mushrooms, feta cheese, Kalamata olives. Vegetarian.

New Yorker Pizza

Pepperoni, ham, bacon, sausage, roasted peppers, banana peppers, mushrooms, onions, olives.

Deep Dish Pizza

Make your own.
US$32.50

Sicilian Pizza

Make your own.
US$32.50